I have written previously about St Chad's Cathedral, the mother church of the huge archdiocese of Birmingham. It was about four years ago that Wendy and I discovered this Cathedral, at a time when we were excitedly discovering the Catholic Faith. Pugin designed this church with grand, sweeping 'Sarum' liturgies in mind; the likes of which are probably never going to be seen again owing to the political and heretical problems of the 16th century. The Mass, or any public worship of the Church, is there to reflect and embody the teaching of the Faith. When attacks are made on the integrity of the Faith, it is often the Mass which suffers. Pugin's dream was to recapture a quintessentially English Catholicism, at a time in the nineteenth century when Catholicism was permitted and revived.St Chad's Cathedral was the product of this way of thinking, and in a rare way outdoes the Anglican Cathedral of the city (in my humble opinion). The old English style of liturgy was never re-employed again, mainly because it had been killed off. Now the familiar form of liturgy to Catholics living in this country was the form promulgated following the Council of Trent: the so-called 'Tridentine' Mass. It was thus this barrack against Protestantism, this perfect and timely missal, which was uttered under the great gothic arches of St Chad's.
Since the reform of the liturgy in 1969, the traditional missal had only been employed sparingly; it was as long ago as 1982 that a Mass was said in the Tridentine Rite at St Chad's Cathedral (a Requiem as a dying man's wish). Last year under my suggestion the Brother's of the Little Oratory had a low mass in St Edward's side chapel (a 1930s addition) with the kind permission of the then-Dean, Fr Brian Doolan.











Captious point I realize, but, considering how much Pugin despised Latin vestments, it's a pity that Gothic ones were not used on this occasion.
ReplyDeleteI agree entirely with "Anonymous". There are wonderful vestments already available at St. Chad's. Taking Roman vestments from elsewhere to wear in Pugin's Gothic Church is not only odd, but gives the unfortunate impression that only Roman vestments are permitted in the Extraordinary Form of Mass.
ReplyDeletethe previous commentator is right here. It is most unfortunate to give the impression that only Roman vestments can be used in EF Masses. There are some magnificent Pugin vestments at St. Chad's which, had they been used instead, would indeed have given the kind of convincingly "English Catholic" impression that, as you rightly say in your article, Pugin aimed to convey by his harmonious integration of art and architecture.
ReplyDeleteI do hope that those who arrange other EF masses in Gothic churches will not feel obliged to use Roman vestments!